WESTFIELD — Authorities in Hamilton County are reviving efforts to identify the remains of more than a dozen people found on the former property of notorious serial killer Herbert Baumeister.
Investigators believe at least 25 people fell victim to Baumeister, who police have said lured gay men to his home at Fox Hollow Farms in the mid-80s and 90s and killed them. Baumeister died by suicide shortly after police began their investigation.
To date, 26 years after the discovery of the victims' bodies, only eight have been identified. That leaves 17 whose identities have yet to be determined.
The Hamilton County Coroner's Office said Monday that DNA profiling could help identify those people.
“I think a big challenge in this case is having those comparison family reference samples,” Dr. Krista Latham said.
Dr. Krista Latham, Director of the Human Identification Center at the University of Indianapolis, says the lab has worked to help with the recovery of remains from Baumeister’s property.
“Not only do we have these very powerful data bases that allow for those comparisons we. Wouldn’t have had back in the early ’90s but we are also able to generate DNA profiles that wouldn’t have been candidates for DNA analysis in late ’90s," Dr. Latham said.
In a statement from the center to WRTV it said, the unique challenges associated with this case and the sheer volume of samples created a situation where advances in identification technologies were necessary to attempt the identification of these individuals.
“We have had advances in DNA technology that will allow us to obtain DNA samples from more challenging human remains cases,” Dr. Latham said.
-
38-story Signia Hotel construction ahead of schedule thanks to mild weather
The tower on Georgia and Illinois Streets will be 38 stories high when it is finished. Crews have built 9 of its 38 stories since work started in June.
IMPD: 1 killed, 1 critically injured in southwest side shooting
One person is dead, and another is in critical condition following a shooting near Howard and Lee Streets on the southwest side of Indianapolis Friday afternoon.
Notre Dame and Penn State will renew a long-dormant rivalry in a CFP semifinal
Notre Dame and Penn State have played 19 times but not since 2007. Each team has won nine times in the series and there was one tie.
Indianapolis Homicide Map
In 2024, Indianapolis recorded 209 homicides making it one of the deadliest years in the city's history. Here's a look at the 2025 homicide data for Marion County.
